🤫 20 counter-intuitive lessons from 500+ consumer founders (part 2)

The best consumer founders know the game. 26K+ of them read Consumer Startups every week.

Stay ahead. Get the playbook behind today's breakout startups.

Read time: 3 mins 19 seconds

A word from our partner

If CRMs were invented today, they’d probably look like Attio.

(No offense to the ones still stuck in 2012)

Connect your email and calendar, and Attio instantly builds a CRM that matches your business model — with all your companies, contacts, and interactions enriched with actionable insights.

It’s AI-native, not “AI duct-taped on later.” Which means you can:

Granola, Flatfile, Replicate, and other sharp operators are already using it.

🎁 Attio’s giving Consumer Startups readers two weeks free to see what an actually modern CRM feels like.

In case you missed the first part last week, check it out here.

This week, we'll dive into the next 10 counter-intuitive lessons from interviewing 500+ consumer founders over the past 5 years, with a focus on growth and monetization.

Reddit is THE BIGGEST early growth driver for 3 out of 10 consumer founders I interviewed in the past 2 months. But it's not as simple as dropping links in relevant subreddits.

Allermi (an 8-figure allergy care brand) didn't promote their personalized nasal spray directly on Reddit. Instead, they chose the educational route. They hosted AMAs with a Stanford allergist, who happens to be Allermi's cofounder, under the title: "Stanford allergist here to answer questions." One post pulled in 800+ upvotes and translated into huge trust-driven conversions.

The key is to be a genuine community member who provides value first. As I detailed in my Reddit customer acquisition guide, you need to build credibility through expertise and storytelling, not direct promotion.

In the early days, you have to do whatever it takes to get your first 1000 customers. Many of them might not be scalable.

Simplify (AI job board) used Squid Game-themed business cards distributed across university campuses when traditional marketing failed.

Morty (immersive experience marketplace) mailed homemade cookies to venue owners with no immediate ask, fostering genuine relationships.

Neighbor (self storage marketplace) used creative tactics like leaving dollar bills on flyers with "Here's the first dollar you'll make" for a $1 customer acquisition cost.

I wrote about how different consumer startups got their first 1000 customers. There are many different ways to get your first 100 customers. Go wild!

You don’t need MrBeast or a Kardashian to make influencer marketing work. Micro-influencers with <1,000 followers consistently outperform mega-influencers.

Sekai (interactive storytelling app) tried big influencers first. Complete flop. Then they switched to micro-influencers paying $5-10 per video. These creators joined their Discord, became genuine advocates, and drove massive growth.

Praktika (AI language learning app) found a Brazilian TikTok creator with 10K followers generating 2-3M views per video. They "acquihired" him, and he's been killing it for the company.

Going viral is great, but most founders aren't prepared to capitalize on it.

Fazit had a "viral emergency kit" ready when Taylor Swift wore their product: existing manufacturing relationships, social media response plans, and retail expansion strategies.

Viral moments are fleeting. Preparation converts them into sustained growth.

Kickstarter isn't only a good fundraising platform. It can be a great customer validation and acquisition channel.

Hallow used their Kickstarter campaign to validate demand, build an email list of early adopters, gather market research, and create social proof, all while raising $25K+ from 300+ backers.

Inkbox benefited a ton from Kickstarter. Within two weeks of their Kickstarter campaign, they hit their $40K goal. A month later, they blew past their stretch goal and hit $180K. In total, they raised nearly $300K from over 7,500 backers.

User-generated content (UGC) is still the channel with the most growth upside. However, you can't just ask creators to make content and hope for the best.

As I covered in my UGC playbook, you need a system that can help you find and scale winning formats at scale.

Here is a cheat sheet:

Most founders obsess over referral mechanics when they should study natural sharing behavior.

Wispr Flow discovered only 5% of referrals used their "give $x get $x" program. Users were sharing like they recommend restaurants—wanting credit for the discovery, not rewards.

So they completely ignored their referral flow and instead pivoted their focus on reaching natural advocates vocal on social media.

Result: >60% month-over-month growth.

Smart founders shift customer acquisition costs to other parties.

Take Zogo, a financial literacy app for teens. It's free, and even pays teens rewards, funded entirely by banks. Banks license Zogo as a white-label product and cover all marketing + rewards. Zogo provides the platform. It grew to millions of users and was acquired for a mid-8-figure all-cash offer.

Or look at Fay, a dietitian marketplace last valued at $500M. The platform is free for dietitians and patients because insurance covers the costs.

Find the channel where someone else happily funds your growth.

Most products optimize for frictionless experiences. Sometimes friction improves outcomes.

Curated (expert advice marketplace) intentionally adds friction by requiring customers to talk to an expert, leading to higher conversion rates and average order values.

For complex or high-value decisions, friction can improve match quality and customer satisfaction.

Most early-stage founders overcomplicate pricing research when simple research works better.

Wispr Flow rejected complex Van Westendorp pricing analysis and used four simple questions with range sliders: What price feels fair? Too premium but might pay? Too expensive? Too cheap?

Then decide: consumer product (lean toward fair price for broad adoption, like Notion) or prosumer product (lean toward expensive-but-acceptable for higher revenue, like Superhuman).

Wispr Flow chose the consumer approach and achieved ~20% paid conversion rate, far above the typical 3–4% benchmark.

—

What are some counter-intuitive things you've learned in your startup journey? I'd love to hear from you!

See you next Tuesday,

Leo

btw.. give Attio a try. AI-native CRM, 2 weeks free.

Follow me on X and LinkedIn

📥️ Want to advertise in Consumer Startups? Learn more.